Reviewed September 7, 2026.
The answer depends on the project and the actual chain of contracts. Labels such as “third tier” or “supplier” do not replace a review of who hired whom and what each participant provided.
Private improvements
Read the definitions in Lien Law § 2 together with the lien right in § 3. The subcontractor definition reaches agreements with subcontractors, while the materialman definition identifies the parties to whom materials are furnished. A contractor supplying labor and services is not necessarily equivalent to a dealer that only resells materials.
In New York Concrete Washout Systems, Inc. v. Naylor Construction, Inc. (Sup Ct 2024), the court examined the actual contracting chain and services rather than treating a numerical tier label as decisive. That does not establish that every remote supplier can lien every private project.
Public improvements and bonds
Section 5 governs public-improvement liens and has its own eligibility limits. Payment-bond rights arise under a separate statute or bond and may use different tiers and notice rules. Qualifying for one remedy does not establish qualification for the others.
Draw a contracting chart, collect purchase orders and subcontracts, distinguish labor or services from material resale, and determine the available unpaid funds. Eligibility, lien-fund limits, timing and service must all be satisfied before a lien can provide meaningful security.
Kushnick Pallaci PLLC assists clients throughout New York with contractor and supplier lien rights. Contact 631-752-7100 or vtp@kushnicklaw.com.
Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice.
No comments:
Post a Comment