One of the great things about the practice of law is that lawyers (and Judges) have an uncanny ability to take the abundantly clear and simple and make it complex and vague. Case in point is the 4th Department's recent decision in Leonard E. Reidl Const., Inc. v. Homeyer. Apparently the contractor, Leonard E. Riedl Construction, Inc., provided the owners, the Homeyers, with a "Final Waiver and Affidavit." The Waiver stated that the project was "fully completed" and that "all bills for labor and/or materials furnished in connection with the construction of said buildings and work of improvement have been fully paid." Finally, it very clearly said that the contractor "waives any and all lien rights which he may have or may have had on account of or arising out of the construction of said buildings and work of improvement." The case made its way to trial and the trial court found that the parties did not treat the document signed by contractor's representative as a final and complete waiver of any further claims by contractor. The court further found that payments made by the owners after the final waiver constituted evidence that there was a separate side verbal agreement outside of the signed Final Lien Waiver. In affirming the trial court, the Appellate Division noted that "where a waiver form purports to acknowledge that no further payments are owed, but the parties' conduct indicates otherwise, the instrument will not be construed as a release."
Well, having made this same argument myself (successfully), I have to agree that a lien waiver (especially a final lien waiver) is not always a a final waiver and sometimes it isn't even a waiver. This was a classic example of why attorneys are needed in all phases of the construction process and why just following basic advice is not always enough. Home owners are increasingly knowledgeable about lien waivers and especially where lenders are involved the lien waivers are becoming a common requirement on a construction project. However, if you tell the average owner that obtaining a signed document from the contractor wherein the contractor states the work is complete and paid for sometimes is not enough, you will likely be met with a blank look (and probably next with the owner searching Google on his or her phone for a new attorney that surely must know more than you).
The bottom line here is that all contracts, riders, liens, lien waivers, releases, certificates of insurance and insurance policies are not created equally. They must each be looked at within the context of the specific situation to determine how the written document will be applied and interpreted by a Court.
Vincent T. Pallaci is a partner with the New York law firm of Kushnick | Pallaci, PLLC. With offices in Buffalo, New York and Long Island, New York, KP serves the construction industry in each of New York's counties.
Showing posts with label Final Lien Waiver. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Final Lien Waiver. Show all posts
Thursday, May 2, 2013
Saturday, October 23, 2010
Lien Release Dos and Don'ts
If you are in the construction industry chances are that in some point in time you have either asked for a lien release or been asked to sign a lien release, also known as a lien waiver. But do you take the time to actually read the lien release to see what it is? If not, you should - all releases are not created equally.
A lien release usually comes up when it is time to make payment on a construction project. Whether you are an owner paying a general contractor or a general contractor paying a subcontractor or supplier, lien releases are key to the payment process. The lien release essentially says that the contractor or supplier has been paid for his, her or its services and waives the right to file a mechanic's lien against the property or project. Because of the consequences of signing a lien waiver or a lien release, you should make sure that you do it right and that you understand the difference between the types of lien releases.
The first thing you should do is read the release. Specifically, look for the following:
1. Does the lien waiver refer to the correct project?
2. Is the time period referenced in the lien waiver the period for which you are receiving payment and waiving your lien right?
3. Is the release/waiver a partial lien waiver or a final lien waiver?
4. Is the amount set forth in the lien waiver the correct amount that you have been paid?
5. Are the names of the parties in the lien waiver correct?
6. Is the release/waiver conditional on payment or unconditional?
Final Waivers
A final lien waiver means that you have been paid in full and are forever waiving any right to file a mechanic's lien against the project and property. The final lien waiver should be signed at the end of the project in connection with your final payment.
Partial Waivers
A partial lien waiver means that you have received a partial payment, or are receiving a partial payment, and that you waive the right to file a mechanic's lien for that particular portion of the labor or materials that you provided as identified in the lien waiver. Determining whether the lien release you are signing is a final or partial lien waiver can sometimes be difficult. Often the document will have a title as either "Partial Lien Waiver" or "Final Lien Waiver" but, even if it does, read it. Regardless of the title, make sure that the document actually says that you are doing what you think you are doing. If it is final, that is what the release should say. If it is partial, it should say that.
Helpful Lien Waiver Tips
An important tip, which seems self evident, is to make sure that you actually are paid before you sign the release. In almost all instances the lien release or the lien waiver says that you are acknowledging receipt of payment and are waiving your right to file a mechanic's lien. If you have not been paid and the release is not conditional then don't sign it! Now, of course there are situations where payment will not be released until you sign and provide the lien waiver. A simultaneous exchange is acceptable. You hand the lien waiver to the person that is paying you and they in turn hand you a check. Simple enough.
If you are not paid first, or simultaneously with the exchange of the lien waiver, you should try to sign a document known as a "conditional" lien waiver or a "conditional" lien release. The conditional lien waiver includes language that limits the effectiveness of the waiver to the extent of payment actually received. If you are offering a conditional lien waiver expect a fight from the general contractor and/or the project owner. Owners and general contractors don't like conditional releases and waivers. More importantly, banks don't like them. So if your project is financed through a construction loan it is possible that the conditional waiver will not be accepted because disbursements under the construction loan will not be made until unconditional lien waivers are received.
One final note, remember that in New York, a pre-lien waiver is void against public policy. That means that when you start the project nobody can require you to waive your right to file a mechanic's lien before you actually provide the labor and materials. If they do, the waiver is void and is not enforceable. That does not mean you should sign the pre-lien waiver anyway. Explain that the lien waiver is void and that you will not waive your right to file a mechanic's lien until you are paid for your services. Knowing your legal rights is a critical component to the contract negotiation phase.
Even though lien releases and lien waivers are common in the construction industry, they are still important legal documents. As with any legal documents, I strongly suggest that you consult with legal counsel before signing a mechanic's lien waiver or a mechanic's lien release. Often it only takes a few minutes for an experienced construction attorney to review the waiver, make any necessary changes and get it back to you. The small cost for the review can save you a lot of time and money down the line.
Vincent T. Pallaci is a partner at the New York law firm of Kushnick Pallaci, PLLC where his practice focuses primarily on the area of construction law. Kushnick | Pallaci has offices in Buffalo, New York and Long Island, New York allowing it to provide legal counsel to the construction industry across the State.
A lien release usually comes up when it is time to make payment on a construction project. Whether you are an owner paying a general contractor or a general contractor paying a subcontractor or supplier, lien releases are key to the payment process. The lien release essentially says that the contractor or supplier has been paid for his, her or its services and waives the right to file a mechanic's lien against the property or project. Because of the consequences of signing a lien waiver or a lien release, you should make sure that you do it right and that you understand the difference between the types of lien releases.
The first thing you should do is read the release. Specifically, look for the following:
1. Does the lien waiver refer to the correct project?
2. Is the time period referenced in the lien waiver the period for which you are receiving payment and waiving your lien right?
3. Is the release/waiver a partial lien waiver or a final lien waiver?
4. Is the amount set forth in the lien waiver the correct amount that you have been paid?
5. Are the names of the parties in the lien waiver correct?
6. Is the release/waiver conditional on payment or unconditional?
Final Waivers
A final lien waiver means that you have been paid in full and are forever waiving any right to file a mechanic's lien against the project and property. The final lien waiver should be signed at the end of the project in connection with your final payment.
Partial Waivers
A partial lien waiver means that you have received a partial payment, or are receiving a partial payment, and that you waive the right to file a mechanic's lien for that particular portion of the labor or materials that you provided as identified in the lien waiver. Determining whether the lien release you are signing is a final or partial lien waiver can sometimes be difficult. Often the document will have a title as either "Partial Lien Waiver" or "Final Lien Waiver" but, even if it does, read it. Regardless of the title, make sure that the document actually says that you are doing what you think you are doing. If it is final, that is what the release should say. If it is partial, it should say that.
Helpful Lien Waiver Tips
An important tip, which seems self evident, is to make sure that you actually are paid before you sign the release. In almost all instances the lien release or the lien waiver says that you are acknowledging receipt of payment and are waiving your right to file a mechanic's lien. If you have not been paid and the release is not conditional then don't sign it! Now, of course there are situations where payment will not be released until you sign and provide the lien waiver. A simultaneous exchange is acceptable. You hand the lien waiver to the person that is paying you and they in turn hand you a check. Simple enough.
If you are not paid first, or simultaneously with the exchange of the lien waiver, you should try to sign a document known as a "conditional" lien waiver or a "conditional" lien release. The conditional lien waiver includes language that limits the effectiveness of the waiver to the extent of payment actually received. If you are offering a conditional lien waiver expect a fight from the general contractor and/or the project owner. Owners and general contractors don't like conditional releases and waivers. More importantly, banks don't like them. So if your project is financed through a construction loan it is possible that the conditional waiver will not be accepted because disbursements under the construction loan will not be made until unconditional lien waivers are received.
One final note, remember that in New York, a pre-lien waiver is void against public policy. That means that when you start the project nobody can require you to waive your right to file a mechanic's lien before you actually provide the labor and materials. If they do, the waiver is void and is not enforceable. That does not mean you should sign the pre-lien waiver anyway. Explain that the lien waiver is void and that you will not waive your right to file a mechanic's lien until you are paid for your services. Knowing your legal rights is a critical component to the contract negotiation phase.
Even though lien releases and lien waivers are common in the construction industry, they are still important legal documents. As with any legal documents, I strongly suggest that you consult with legal counsel before signing a mechanic's lien waiver or a mechanic's lien release. Often it only takes a few minutes for an experienced construction attorney to review the waiver, make any necessary changes and get it back to you. The small cost for the review can save you a lot of time and money down the line.
Vincent T. Pallaci is a partner at the New York law firm of Kushnick Pallaci, PLLC where his practice focuses primarily on the area of construction law. Kushnick | Pallaci has offices in Buffalo, New York and Long Island, New York allowing it to provide legal counsel to the construction industry across the State.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)