Showing posts with label Contents of Lien. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Contents of Lien. Show all posts

Friday, October 21, 2011

Disputing a Mechanic’s Lien Amount: Use the Correct Procedure

Reviewed September 7, 2026.

Disagreeing with the amount of a mechanic’s lien does not, by itself, establish a facial defect permitting summary discharge under Lien Law § 19(6). The procedure is limited to the statutory grounds; it does not resolve every disagreement over payment, completion or performance.

Separate the issues

A notice may fail a required element, contain a disputed factual statement, include an overstated balance or be intentionally exaggerated. Those are not interchangeable conclusions. Gather contracts, payments, credits, work records and the filed notice before choosing a remedy.

In Broadway PT 1710 LLC v. Kingdom Associates, Inc. (1st Dept 2026), the court rejected a § 19(6) challenge based on issues beyond the notice’s face. It also explained that a § 38 itemization demand did not justify discharge without the required prior compliance order.

Exaggeration and accelerated enforcement

Willful exaggeration under §§ 39 and 39-a requires proof of intent, not merely a lower amount ultimately awarded. Contrary to an earlier version of this article, it need not always await a trial: Northe Group, Inc. v. Spread NYC, LLC (2011) permits summary disposition on conclusive evidence.

A § 59 demand is a separate statutory process with proper service, a deadline at least 30 days later and a court application if necessary. It is not a substitute for answering an existing foreclosure action or an automatic cancellation notice.

Kushnick Pallaci PLLC assists clients throughout New York with Section 59 demands and lien disputes. Contact 631-752-7100 or vtp@kushnicklaw.com.

Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice.

Sunday, May 15, 2011

Can You Amend a New York Mechanic’s Lien?

Reviewed September 7, 2026.

A correction to a New York mechanic’s lien depends on the type of error and the statutory procedure. Lien Law § 12-a provides two distinct routes; the sixty-day rule is not the deadline for every possible court-ordered amendment.

Reducing the amount without a court amendment order

Under subdivision 1, a lienor may amend within sixty days after original filing, on twenty days’ notice to existing lienors, mortgagees and the owner, where the purpose is to reduce the amount and no proceeding to enforce or cancel the lien has been brought in the meantime. A willful-exaggeration issue survives the reduction. Reducing an inflated lien does not automatically eliminate potential liability.

Asking the court to correct a notice

Subdivision 2 permits a court, in a proper case and on five days’ notice to existing lienors, mortgagees and the owner, to amend a public- or private-improvement notice retroactively. The amendment may not prejudice an existing lienor, mortgagee or good-faith purchaser.

Some nonjurisdictional errors can be corrected. For example, Matter of CAFS Management Corp. v. Q Realty & Development allowed correction of the lienor’s corporate name. That does not mean every missing element, expired lien or newly asserted claim can be repaired.

Do not use amendment to enlarge the claim

An amendment is not a way to increase the lien amount. If additional unpaid work may support a new notice, counsel must separately evaluate eligibility, timely filing, duplication, service and any existing proceedings. An amendment also does not automatically extend the lien’s duration. Review the original notice, requested change, prejudice and all deadlines before acting.

Kushnick Pallaci PLLC assists clients throughout New York with mechanic’s lien amendment and defense. Contact 631-752-7100 or vtp@kushnicklaw.com.

Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice.

Saturday, April 16, 2011

Can a New York Mechanic’s Lien Include Attorneys’ Fees?

Reviewed September 7, 2026.

A mechanic’s lien is security for a qualifying construction debt. It does not automatically secure every expense of collecting that debt.

Keep the lien amount separate from a fee claim

Lien Law § 3 protects the principal and interest of the value or agreed price of qualifying labor and materials. The measure is not simply the contractor’s out-of-pocket cost. Payments, credits, unperformed work and other adjustments must be addressed when calculating the unpaid lienable balance.

Attorneys’ fees incurred pursuing payment ordinarily should not be added to the notice of lien as though they were labor or materials used in the improvement. An enforceable contractual fee clause may support a separate request for reasonable attorneys’ fees in the collection action, but it does not automatically enlarge the property lien.

Other fee rights need their own legal basis

New York generally requires each party to bear its own attorneys’ fees unless a statute, court rule or enforceable agreement provides otherwise. For example, Lien Law § 39-a provides specified relief after a lien is declared void for willful exaggeration in a qualifying enforcement proceeding. That is a distinct statutory remedy, not permission for a lienor to insert anticipated litigation fees into the lien.

Prepare separate calculations for the unpaid contract balance, lienable amount, claimed interest and any fee request. Counsel should review the governing agreement and the legal basis for each before filing.

Kushnick Pallaci PLLC assists clients throughout New York with mechanic’s lien filing and defense. Contact 631-752-7100 or vtp@kushnicklaw.com.

Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice.

Saturday, March 26, 2011

Interest and Finance Charges in a New York Mechanic’s Lien

Reviewed September 7, 2026.

Lien Law § 3 expressly recognizes principal and interest on the value or agreed price of qualifying labor and materials. That does not make every charge labeled “interest,” “finance charge” or “late fee” automatically lienable.

Establish the legal basis and calculation

Review the contract, invoice terms, payment due dates, credits and applicable law. An enforceable agreed interest provision may support interest on overdue sums. A charge first printed on an invoice is not necessarily an agreed contract term, and a penalty or other unenforceable charge cannot be justified merely by giving it a different name.

The absence of a contractual interest clause does not necessarily eliminate a right to interest in litigation. CPLR 5001 governs prejudgment interest, and CPLR 5004 contains rates and exceptions. Counsel should distinguish the amount stated in the notice, interest accruing on the underlying debt and interest awarded by the court.

Keep a transparent ledger

Show principal separately from interest, identify the rate and accrual dates, and apply payments and credits consistently. Review any compounding, finance-charge, penalty or usury issue before filing. Do not add unsupported charges or claim the same interest twice.

Kushnick Pallaci PLLC assists clients throughout New York with mechanic’s lien preparation and disputes. Contact 631-752-7100 or vtp@kushnicklaw.com.

Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice.

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Contractor Licensing and Lien Filing: Updating an Old Certification Proposal

Reviewed September 7, 2026.

This post originally criticized a proposed requirement for a county certification before recording a mechanic’s lien. That historical proposal is not a substitute for checking current law and the filing requirements that apply to a particular project.

Check licensing before the work and before collection

Current Lien Law § 9 sets out notice contents. A clerk’s acceptance of a notice does not establish that the contractor held the licenses needed to perform the work or that the lien can be enforced.

Licensing depends on the location, trade, type of work and contracting entity. The New York Attorney General’s home-improvement guidance identifies local licensing requirements in New York City and several counties. Other local or trade-specific requirements may also apply.

For covered consumer claims, CPLR 3015(e) requires allegations about the license held when services were rendered. A later license does not automatically cure an earlier deficiency.

The risk is more than losing a lien

The earlier suggestion that an unlicensed contractor risks only its lien was too narrow. Depending on the applicable law, unlicensed work can affect payment recovery and expose the contractor to regulatory penalties or other relief. Verify the correct entity’s license and its effective dates, obtain required permits and retain supporting records.

Kushnick Pallaci PLLC assists clients throughout New York with construction contract and compliance review. Contact 631-752-7100 or vtp@kushnicklaw.com.

Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice.

Wednesday, April 21, 2010

Out-of-State Corporations Filing New York Mechanic’s Liens

Reviewed September 7, 2026.

An out-of-state corporation should review its entity information, addresses and authority to do business before filing or enforcing a New York mechanic’s lien.

Use accurate information in the notice

Lien Law § 9 requires the prescribed lienor and business information, including a foreign corporation’s principal place of business within New York. It also calls for the lienor’s attorney’s name and address, “if any.” Do not invent a New York business address.

Courts have addressed how a corporation with no actual New York office can comply. In Nistler Carpentry, Inc. v. Gangcarz (Sup Ct 2018), the notice’s New York attorney information satisfied the address issue. In Matter of Superior Maintenance Group (Sup Ct 2009), the court declined to read the statute as universally requiring a corporation without a New York office to hire an attorney merely to file its lien. These decisions do not support a categorical rule that every out-of-state lien is invalid without a New York attorney address.

Filing and capacity to sue are separate

Business Corporation Law § 1312 restricts an unauthorized foreign corporation doing business in New York from maintaining an action until statutory requirements are met, while preserving specified other rights. Whether the corporation is “doing business” for that purpose requires analysis of its activities. Review any applicable licensing requirements as well.

Verify the legal entity name, genuine business addresses, required registrations, attorney information if represented, and all lien filing and service requirements before submission.

Kushnick Pallaci PLLC assists clients throughout New York with New York mechanic’s lien preparation and enforcement. Contact 631-752-7100 or vtp@kushnicklaw.com.

Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice.

Friday, January 15, 2010

Mechanic’s Liens on New York Condominiums: Units, Common Elements and Trust Funds

Reviewed September 7, 2026.

A recorded condominium declaration changes the lien analysis, but it does not mean that contractors can never file liens after conversion or after a unit has been sold.

Individual units and common elements differ

Real Property Law § 339-l provides that, after the declaration is recorded, liens generally arise against individual units and their respective common interests. A lien against common elements requires unanimous unit-owner consent. Work on a unit generally cannot support a lien against a unit owner who did not expressly consent or request it, subject to the emergency-repair exception.

A unit’s sale is not, by itself, a universal prohibition on a later lien. Review who requested the work, ownership and recording dates, the declaration, the work location, purchaser protections and the applicable Lien Law requirements. Do not file a blanket lien against the entire condominium based only on an unpaid invoice.

Common-charge trust protection

Section 339-l also makes common charges received and receivable by the board, and the right to receive them, trust funds for the specified costs of common-element work requested or consented to by the manager, managing agent or board. That may provide a remedy even where a lien against the common elements is unavailable. It does not make every condominium charge a trust asset for every contractor regardless of authorization or work performed.

Obtain the contract, approvals, declaration, unit identification and payment records early. Condominium and cooperative ownership structures differ and should not be treated as interchangeable. Related claims may involve construction trust funds or a direct contract.

Kushnick Pallaci PLLC assists clients throughout New York with mechanic’s lien filing and defense. Contact 631-752-7100 or vtp@kushnicklaw.com.

Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice.

Wednesday, September 23, 2009

Naming the Correct Property Owner in a New York Mechanic’s Lien

Reviewed September 7, 2026.

Identify the legal owner and the interest being liened before filing. A contract, tax record or conversation with a company principal may not establish current title.

The Carnegie Hill dispute

In Matter of Carnegie Hill North LLC v. Diontech Consulting Inc., 25 Misc 3d 1203(A) (Sup Ct, NY County 2009), a lien named an individual associated with related companies rather than the LLC holding title. The parties disputed what had been said about ownership, the relationship among the businesses and the significance of a contract describing a ground lease.

The court held the discharge and amendment motions in abeyance and referred factual issues to a special referee. That interim decision did not finally authorize the amendment or establish that all owner-name errors are fatal.

Some mistakes can be corrected; others threaten the lien

Lien Law § 9 contains protection for specified omissions or misdescriptions, and § 12-a permits certain amendments. Courts distinguish curable mistakes from material defects by examining the notice and circumstances, including affected interests and prejudice.

Obtain current ownership information, review the deed and relevant lease or condominium records, and match the legal entity and property description to the claimed interest. A title search is a useful precaution; it does not replace analysis of owner consent or guarantee the lien’s validity. Address any discovered error promptly before deadlines or intervening rights make correction more difficult.

Kushnick Pallaci PLLC assists clients throughout New York with mechanic’s lien filing and defense. Contact 631-752-7100 or vtp@kushnicklaw.com.

Attorney Advertising. General information, not legal advice.